If you liked The Lake House by Kate Morton…
Girl on the Train by Paula Hawkins: This murder mystery reminded greatly of the first half of Gone Girl. I didn't finish Gone Girl because I had already seen the movie, and they were almost identical. This novel lends itself even more traditionally in the mystery genre, but it had just enough depth that I really enjoyed it.
Based in pastoral England
By Kate Morton
Trust me, if you liked The Lake House, you will like any of Kate Morton's novels. They all have unique stories and characters, but have the same basic skeleton. You'll love them all or none of them.
Do you have any recommendations if you like Kate Morton?